The New Rules for Fixing Retirement Plan Mistakes – The Exclusive Benefit Podcast
A new office manager at a small orthodontics practice starts going through his predecessor’s files and finds three problems in one week: a participant loan nobody defaulted, three new hires who were never auto-enrolled, and a plan amendment that’s been sitting unsigned since 2022. A month ago, that was two filings with the IRS and six months of waiting. Today it’s three self-corrections and a memo in the file. In this episode I use one employer’s bad week to explain Rev. Proc. 2026-34, the first full rewrite of the IRS plan correction program since 2021: the single idea at its center, why far more mistakes can now be fixed in-house without a fee, why plans no longer have to chase retirees for honest overpayments, and the one thing the IRS wants from you in exchange. For employers with a 401(k), 403(b), SEP or SIMPLE, and the CPAs and advisors who serve them.
Listen to the episode here:
ERISA requires plan fiduciaries to act for the exclusive benefit of participants. On this podcast, Angela Stockbridge does the same for listeners. The Exclusive Benefit explains retirement plans, health and welfare benefits, and executive compensation in plain English. Each episode takes on a real issue that plan sponsors, HR professionals, CPAs, and financial advisors face, such as compliance deadlines, plan corrections, required minimum distributions, and benefits in M&A deals. Get practical guidance on what the rules require, where the risks are, and what to do next, without the legal jargon.
This podcast may be considered attorney advertising. This podcast is not presented for purposes of legal advice or for providing a legal opinion. Before any of the presenting attorneys can provide legal advice to any person or entity, and before an attorney-client relationship is formed, that attorney must have a signed fee agreement with a client setting forth the firm’s scope of representation and the fees that will be charged.
Transcript:
**This transcript has been prepared automatically by AI and may contain inaccuracies**
Angela Stockbridge [00:00:22]:
Welcome to The Exclusive Benefit. I’m Angela Stockbridge. Before we start, the usual. This is general information. Not legal advice. And listening doesn’t make you my client. The facts always matter, so talk to your own attorney or tax advisor before you act on anything you hear. If you’d like that to be me, my contact information is in the show notes.
Angela Stockbridge [00:00:42]:
Okay, I want to tell you a story about a dental practice. This is a made-up practice, and I’m going to call it Riverbend Orthodontics. But all of these things that happen to this made-up orthodontic practice are things that have happened to real clients. Maybe not all of them to one client, but to some clients of mine. I’m telling you this because on October 22nd, the IRS rewrote the rules for fixing retirement plan mistakes. Revenue Procedure 2026-34. The easiest way I know how to explain what changed is to take one employer, walk through a bad week, and show you how the answer in that week is different today than it was before October 22nd, 2026. By the end, you’ll understand the one idea at the center of the new rules.
Angela Stockbridge [00:01:31]:
You’ll know why a lot of problems that used to require a filing with the IRS now don’t, and you’ll know the one thing the IRS wants from you in exchange. Riverbend Orthodontics has 2 doctors, about 35 employees, and a 401 plan with automatic enrollment. The person who ran the plan for 15 years was an office manager, and let’s call her Diane. Diane retired in the spring. Her replacement is Marcus. Marcus is sharp, organized, and curious. And in his second month, Marcus starts opening drawers. Monday, Marcus finds the first thing.
Angela Stockbridge [00:02:09]:
One of the dental assistants took a loan from the plan back in 2021. She went on leave, her payments stopped, she came back to work, And payroll never restarted the deduction. That loan should have been treated as defaulted and taxed years ago. Nobody did anything. It’s just sitting there on the recordkeeper’s report with a little asterisk. Wednesday, Marcus finds the second thing. The plan automatically enrolls new hires at 4%. 3 people hired in 2025 were never enrolled.
Angela Stockbridge [00:02:40]:
Payroll set them up, but the deferral flag didn’t get checked. One of the 3 has already left the practice. On Friday, he finds the 3rd thing. The plan document was supposed to be amended for a law change back in 2022. The document provider sent the amendment. It’s in a folder. It was never signed. So Marcus calls the doctors, and the doctors call me, and the first question is the one every client asks: how bad is this? Here’s what I would have told them before October 22nd.
Angela Stockbridge [00:03:08]:
The loan That’s a loan failure. And under the 2021 Rev. Proc., most loan failures had to go to the IRS through the Voluntary Correction Program, a filing, a user fee, and a few months of waiting. The auto enrollment, there was a safe harbor that let you skip the employer makeup contribution, but it had expired at the end of 2023. There was a statute and then IRS notice saying, keep going, we’ll write the rules eventually. So you were relying on interim guidance. It was workable, but it was uncomfortable, and nobody was sure whether it covered the employee who had already left. The unsigned amendment.
Angela Stockbridge [00:03:47]:
That is a plan document failure. Self-correction was only available if you had a favorable determination letter and it was within 3 years. Riverbend had neither. 4 years had passed, so that was a VCP filing too. Add it up, and a month ago, Riverbend was looking at 1, probably 2 filings with the IRS, user fees, my time preparing them, and 6 months of waiting for a compliance statement for 3 honest mistakes in a well-run plan. Now that’s the before. Let me tell you what changed. The whole rewrite comes down to one idea, and if you remember nothing else from this episode, remember this: the old rules sorted mistakes into boxes— operational failure, Document failure, demographic failure, eligibility failure, significant or insignificant.
Angela Stockbridge [00:04:37]:
Each box had its own rule about whether you could fix it yourself and how long you had. The boxes were the system. The new rules throw out the boxes and ask one question instead: Was this an eligible inadvertent failure? That phrase comes straight from Secure 2.0, and it means something specific. Did the employer have reasonable procedures in place to run the plan correctly, and did the mistake happen anyway? If yes, and if the mistake isn’t egregious, doesn’t involve anyone stealing from the plan, and isn’t part of a tax shelter, then it’s eligible. And eligible means you can fix it yourself. No filing, no fee, no waiting. That’s it. That’s the change.
Angela Stockbridge [00:05:18]:
Everything else is detail. So let’s go back to Riverbend and see what it does for each of their problems. The loan. Diane had a procedure. When someone went on leave, she flagged it, and when they came back, she restarted deductions. She did it dozens of times over 15 years. Once she missed. That is the textbook definition of an eligible inadvertent failure.
Angela Stockbridge [00:05:40]:
Good procedure, followed routinely, one slip. Under the new rules, Riverbend fixes the loan itself. The common loan errors, missed payments, loans over the limit, bad amortization schedules are all now expressly self-correctable. Depending on the facts, Marcus either gets the assistant to catch up and re-amortize, or the plan reports the deemed distribution and she picks up the income. Either way, it’s handled in-house, documented in the file, and done. One footnote I want to give: the Department of Labor has its own view of participant loans and fixing it with with the IRS doesn’t automatically square it with the DOL. That’s a short conversation and not a filing, but it is a conversation that has to be had. The auto enrollment— the safe harbor that expired in 2023 is now permanent.
Angela Stockbridge [00:06:32]:
It’s written into the Rev. Proc. and it works like this: if Riverbend starts the correct deferrals for those 3 employees by the end of a 9.5-month window after the plan year of the mistake, gives each of them a written notice within 45 days of deferrals starting, and puts in whatever match they would have gotten with earnings, then Riverbend doesn’t have to make the employer contribution that normally replaces the missed deferrals. That’s real money. On a 4% deferral for 3 people over most of a year, that is thousands of dollars that Riverbend keeps. And the employee who left? The old guidance didn’t say. The new rev proc does. The safe harbor applies to people who’ve already terminated.
Angela Stockbridge [00:07:15]:
Riverbend sends her the notice and the match, same as the other 2. One more thing here, because it will matter to some of you. This safe harbor used to be only for 401 and 403 plans. It now covers SEP and SIMPLE plans too. If you’ve got a small business client on a SIMPLE with an auto-enrollment feature, they just got the same relief. The unsigned amendment. This is the one that surprises the doctors because it’s the one that feels the most like a you need a lawyer and a filing type of problem. But 2 things changed.
Angela Stockbridge [00:07:48]:
First, you no longer need a favorable determination letter to self-correct a document failure. Riverbend never had one. Doesn’t matter anymore. Second, the fixed 3-year window is gone. The new standard is that you fix it within a reasonable time after you find it, And the Rev Proc tells you what reasonable means. You’re safe if you finish by the later of the end of the 3rd plan year after the eligible failure or 18 months after you’ve identified it. So let me say that again, 18 months after you have identified it. The amendment should have been signed in 2022.
Angela Stockbridge [00:08:27]:
Marcus found it in 2026. Under the old rules, the window closed in 2025 and Riverbend had to file a VCP. But under the new rules, Riverbend’s clock started the day Marcus opened the folder, and it runs 18 months. The doctors sign the amendment, effective retroactively. Marcus writes a memo for the file, and bing bang boom, that’s the correction. So let’s add it up again. A month ago, 2 IRS filings, user fees, attorney time, and half a year of waiting. Today, 3 self-corrections, a memo in the file, and a short engagement with me to make sure the memo says the right things.
Angela Stockbridge [00:09:09]:
The same mistakes, the same plan, completely different answer. That’s the center of this Rev Proc. The boxes are gone. The question is whether you had procedures and slipped, and if you did, the IRS will let you fix it. I wanna tell you one more story, shorter, because it’s about the other big change, and it’s the one that used to keep me up at night. One of the Riverbend doctors has a mother. Let’s call her Ruth. Ruth is 81.
Angela Stockbridge [00:09:35]:
She retired from a hospital system 20 years ago with a traditional pension. Every month she gets a check. Last year, the hospital’s actuary ran an audit and found that when Ruth retired, somebody used the wrong early retirement factor. Her pension had been overstated by about $140 a month for 20 years. That’s roughly $34,000. Under the old rules, the plan had 2 choices, and both were bad. Go to Ruth and ask for the money back in a lump sum or by cutting her future checks. Have the hospital put $34,000 back into the plan out of its own pocket.
Angela Stockbridge [00:10:14]:
Most plans, for obvious reasons, chose the first one. So an 81-year-old widow gets a letter telling her that she owes her former employer $34,000. This is a terrible letter to have to write. It’s a terrible phone call to have to make. It is a terrible way to treat someone who did nothing wrong. SECURE 2.0 changed the law. The new Rev Proc writes it into the correction rules. For an honest overpayment, an inadvertent benefit overpayment, the plan does not have to recoup that money and the hospital doesn’t have to make the plan whole.
Angela Stockbridge [00:10:47]:
The plan fixes her benefit going forward and the past stays in the past. If the hospital wants, it can amend the plan to say that Ruth was getting what she’s entitled to and keep paying it. Now, there are a few exceptions. If the overpayment happened because the plan blew past one of the hard statutory limits, the compensate— The compensation cap, the benefit cap, or the funding restrictions, the plan does still have to be made whole even though there’s a new pass for anything under $250. And if a plan does decide to go after an overpayment, ERISA has its own separate limits on how, and the rev proc doesn’t change those. But for Ruth and the thousands of retirees like her, the default has flipped. The letter doesn’t get sent. And a small tax point for the CPAs, if the plan doesn’t recoup, the overpayment counts as an eligible rollover.
Angela Stockbridge [00:11:42]:
And a small tax point for the CPAs, If the plan doesn’t recoup, the overpayment counts as an eligible rollover distribution. So if Ruth, or more likely her kids on her behalf, had ever rolled a lump sum into an IRA that included an overpaid piece, that rollover is fine. What’s the catch? So far, all of this sounds like upside. More self-correction, no more chasing retirees, fewer filings. And it is mostly upside. But the IRS is asking for something in return, and it’s the thing that decides whether any of this applies to you. Go back to the definition. An eligible inadvertent failure is one that happens despite reasonable practices and procedures.
Angela Stockbridge [00:12:23]:
Despite. The word despite is doing all the work. Riverbend qualifies because Diane had a system. It was in a binder. It wasn’t fancy, but— Riverbend qualifies because Diane had a system. It was in a binder. It wasn’t fancy, but it existed, and she followed it. She slipped once in 15 years.
Angela Stockbridge [00:12:42]:
If Riverbend had no system in place at all, if loans and enrollments were handled whenever someone remembered, then none of what I just described is available. Not the loan fix, not the auto-enrollment safe harbor, not the 18 months on the amendment. Riverbend would be right back at VCP filing and paying. So the first thing I would ask any employer now is, Show me your procedures. If the answer is a blank look, then that’s the project. Before we fix anything, we have to write down the procedures. Written procedures actually followed are the price of admission to the new rules. The second thing the IRS wants is a paper trail.
Angela Stockbridge [00:13:22]:
Self-correction means nobody looks at your work until an auditor does, and that might be years later. So the file has to tell the story on its own. What the mistake was, when you found it, how you calculated the fix, when you finished it, and what changed so it won’t happen again. Marcus’s memo for the amendment isn’t a formality, it’s the evidence. And the paper trail does one more thing for you. Self-correction has always ended when the IRS shows up for an exam, and that’s still true. But the new Rev. Proc.
Angela Stockbridge [00:13:51]:
says that if you’d already taken specific steps toward fixing a particular problem, before the exam notice arrived, you can finish it. They’re clear about what doesn’t count. A general policy of, we fix things when we find them, doesn’t count. Having an annual audit doesn’t count. Working on that specific problem is what matters. So the day you find something, open the file and start. That’s what protects you if the letter comes 6 months later. Last point on the catch.
Angela Stockbridge [00:14:19]:
Self-correction isn’t always the right call, even when it’s allowed. It gives you no piece of paper from the IRS. If Riverbend were about to be sold, the buyer’s lawyers would want a compliance statement, and Marcus’s memo might not be enough. If the failure is big and messy, or you can’t tell whether it’s inadvertent, VCP is still there, and it might still be worth the filing fee. The new rules give you a choice, but they don’t make it for you. So here’s where Riverbend ends up. 3 mistakes found in 1 week by someone who was curious enough to open the drawer. A month ago, 2 IRS filings and 6 months of waiting.
Angela Stockbridge [00:14:56]:
Today, 3 self-corrections, a good memo, and done before the end of the year. And the doctor’s mother keeps her pension check. If you take one thing from this episode, take this: the IRS has decided to trust employers who have good procedures to fix their own mistakes. That’s a real shift, and it rewards people and organizations that are organized, and it does nothing for people and organizations that are not. So this week, do what Marcus did. Open the drawers, find the binder, or admit that there isn’t one. And if you find something, write it down and start the clock. If you need help with any of that— writing the procedures or deciding whether something is self-correctable or putting it together in a file that will hold up— that’s what I do.
Angela Stockbridge [00:15:40]:
My information is in the show notes. If you’re curious, I also have an episode covering the RevProx Companion, Revenue Procedure 2026-33, which creates the first-ever correction program for IRAs. Missed RMDs, blown rollovers, inherited IRAs that got cashed out by mistake. If you work with individuals, that one’s for you. And one more time, this is general information, not legal advice. Talk to your own advisor about your own plan. I’m Angela Stockbridge, and until next time, this has been The Exclusive Benefit.
